http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=241805Multiplatform:
Devil May Cry 4: 9, 9 (GOTM)
The Club: 8.75, 8.75
Dynasty Warriors 6: 7.25
FIFA Street 3: 7
Turok: 6
Wii:
Dragon Quest Swords: The Masked Queen and the Tower of Mirrors: 7.75, 8
Winter Sports: The Ultimate Challenge: 6.5
No More Heroes: 6, 6
Samurai Warriors: Katana: 6
Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity: 6
Nitrobike: 4.25
PS3:
Lost Planet: Extreme Condition: 8, 8.25
PSP:
God of War: Chains of Olympus: 9, 8.75 (HGOTM)
Patapon: 8.75, 8.5
NDS:
Advance Wars: Days of Ruin: 8.75, 8.75
Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney: 8, 8.5
Rumors:
-Jade Empire 2 is in the works for the 360 and PS3
-Microsoft might buy out logitech
-New peripheral for 360 controller giving it tilt abilities
-Crysis might only make it for the PS3, but EA will probably find a way to bring it to the 360 too.Game Informer Reviews for the month of M ...
NMH.....:( (and didn't MS buy out Logitech arleady?....thanks for the scoop guys)Game Informer Reviews for the month of M ...
6 for No More Heroes? :?Slight difference with GS. Just slight.
Did they mix these two up ? NMH and The Club ?
No More Heroes and Sonic Riders getting the same score?... :
|[QUOTE=''MikeE21286''] (and didn't MS buy out Logitech arleady?....thanks for the scoop guys)[/QUOTE] No and I extremely hope they don't. To be honest all these rumors of MS is going to buy 'X' company is getting real old. Three companies in the past month.
What, no 360 reviews? Oh and BTW, I'm pretty sure Turok got a 7 just like here.
[QUOTE=''Nike_Air'']Did they mix these two up ? NMH and The Club ?[/QUOTE]They must have...
[QUOTE=''gmastersexay''][QUOTE=''MikeE21286''] (and didn't MS buy out Logitech arleady?....thanks for the scoop guys)[/QUOTE] No and I extremely hope they don't. To be honest all these MS is going to buy 'X' company is getting real old. Three companies in the past month. [/QUOTE]Well good thing....I've always MUCH preferred Logitech peripherals for my PC over the Micrcosoft-brand alternatives.
More proof that GI's reviews are craaaazy.
[QUOTE=''Erebyssial''] No More Heroes and Sonic Riders getting the same score?... :|[/QUOTE]Maybe they just really really sucked at it. The game is awesome.
really, the club...but then look at LP on the ps3, i guess that did good too...oh noes no more heroes!
[QUOTE=''goblaa'']More proof that GI's reviews are craaaazy.[/QUOTE]Yeah, there's a thread on neogaf where the editor Andy McNamara defnds their reviews.....I don't think you can defend some of the scores they've been giving out lately though.. '' Of Reviews and Reviews
Andy McNamara
Editor in Chief
Every month it seems that one of our reviews sparks an onslaught of hate or love from gaming's collective conscious through a gaggle of posts on any of the thousands of forums you can find in the great Internet ether or from the emails overflowing in my inbox.
The thing that strikes me every time is that people always seem to assume that we are somehow being paid for our reviews or that we simply don't play the games. The idea that these things are even brought up at all blows my mind, but I figured I might as well cut through the confusion and set the record straight. No company gets favorable treatment for reviews due to an exchange of funds or any other exchange of goods or services.
And to think that we don't play the games is the funniest thing I have ever heard. We work at a video game magazine. We go to work in the morning and have to fire up a Xbox 360. What do you think we do? Shocker: we sit and play games all day at work. But what you may not know is that when the day is over, we go home and play games all night as well. Some might call us crazy, but I call it heaven on Earth.
We love games, and we will always love games. And don't think we don't argue over the reviews ourselves. Any review that the staff sees as too high or too low will always be challenged by the team. The writers are expected to defend their position, but ultimately we do not change game reviews. What the reviewer thinks is what we print. It's that simple.
And in my 17 years of being here at Game Informer we have never ever been banned from a company for a poor review and there is a simple reason why. Companies will not always agree with what we say, but we back up our reviews with research and insight that explains our position and we like or dislike a game.
We don't score a game because we think casual gamers will like it, or hardcore games will like it, or a company will like the review, or a company will hate the review. We give the scores we give because it is what we think of the game. Sometimes you agree with us and sometimes you don't, but don't ever accuse us of not being honest or passionate about videogames, because at the end of the day that's our jobs. But each one of us would walk away from it in a instant if we weren't free to say what we think. So, while you may not agree with us all the time, the opinions you read each and every month are our own.
Enjoy the issue.
Andy''
[QUOTE=''Erebyssial'']No More Heroes and Sonic Riders getting the same score?... :|[/QUOTE]and both got the same score as Samurai Warriors Katana
I shook my head when I saw the scores for The Club and NMH. Seriously, GI?
and GI is more than 2 full points off of the average for NMH.
I tend to agree more with Game Informers reviews when compared to Gamespots. At least in Game Informer they give you 2 opinions in some cases. They shy away from differences between multiplats though where Gamespot will point out differences which is good!
The Club=wintastic.
[QUOTE=''laughingman42'']and GI is more than 2 full points off of the average for NMH.[/QUOTE]They are statisticaly significantly diffrent from the mean score.
[QUOTE=''gmastersexay'']http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=241805Multiplatform:
Devil May Cry 4: 9, 9 (GOTM)
The Club: 8.75, 8.75
Dynasty Warriors 6: 7.25
FIFA Street 3: 7
Turok: 6
Wii:
Dragon Quest Swords: The Masked Queen and the Tower of Mirrors: 7.75, 8
Winter Sports: The Ultimate Challenge: 6.5
No More Heroes: 6, 6
Samurai Warriors: Katana: 6
Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity: 6
Nitrobike: 4.25
PS3:
Lost Planet: Extreme Condition: 8, 8.25
PSP:
God of War: Chains of Olympus: 9, 8.75 (HGOTM)
Patapon: 8.75, 8.5
NDS:
Advance Wars: Days of Ruin: 8.75, 8.75
Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney: 8, 8.5
Rumors:
-Jade Empire 2 is in the works for the 360 and PS3
-Microsoft might buy out logitech
-New peripheral for 360 controller giving it tilt abilities
-Crysis might only make it for the PS3, but EA will probably find a way to bring it to the 360 too.[/QUOTE]A lot of the reviews are accurate but those are just WTF!!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment